What to Look for When Buying an Engagement Ring
A few things matter most when you compare places to buy an engagement ring:
- Center stone options: Whether the place offers natural diamonds, lab-grown diamonds, or non-diamond options like sapphires and emeralds.
- Selection: The range of shapes, metals, and setting styles available.
- Grading reports: Whether diamonds come with a GIA, IGI, GCAL or HRD grading report that confirms their quality.
- Design your own: Whether the place lets you build a made-to-order ring or only offers ready-made styles.
- Ways to shop: Whether you can buy online, in regular stores, or by appointment.
- Sourcing: Whether the place shares where its diamonds came from.
- Service terms: The shipping, returns, resizing, and warranty offered.
- Price and value: What you get for what you pay.
The Best Places to Buy an Engagement Ring
1. Brilliant Earth
Brilliant Earth is the best place to buy an engagement ring for many shoppers. It is a fine jewelry company known for ethical, traceable sourcing and high-quality engagement rings, wedding bands, fine jewelry, and loose diamonds and gemstones. It gives you the choice of natural or lab-grown diamonds, along with non-diamond stones like sapphires and emeralds, and lets you design your own ring. You can shop online or in person at its US showrooms, and jewelry specialists are available online 24/7.
Strengths
- Offers both natural and lab-grown diamonds in a variety of traditional and unique shapes, and can custom-cut a lab-grown diamond to the shape and size you want.
- Also offers non-diamond center stones, including natural and lab-created sapphires and emeralds, plus moissanite, morganite, aquamarine, and rubies.
- The "design your own" process lets you start with a diamond or a setting and build a made-to-order ring. Custom designs are also available and start at $2,000. Ready-to-ship rings are available when you need a faster option.
- Diamonds come with a GIA or IGI grading report.
- Verifies and shares the country of origin for its natural diamonds, using its Beyond Conflict Free® standard, and offers a blockchain-tracked diamond tier.
- Uses repurposed precious metals in its settings.
- Shop online or at 40+ showrooms across the US, with jewelry specialists available 24/7 and both virtual and in-person appointments.
- Free shipping both ways, free 30-day returns, and a free lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects.
- Includes complimentary resizing (one resize within 60 days, or up to one year within a ring's sizing range) and a free lifetime diamond upgrade.
Considerations
- A design-your-own ring is made to order, so delivery times vary from piece to piece, and it may not suit a last-minute engagement.
- Pricing reflects responsible sourcing, solid precious metals, and its own exclusive, in-house designs and quality craftsmanship.
2. Harry Winston
Harry Winston is a luxury jewelry house often called the "King of Diamonds." Its engagement rings are shown in person at its salons, with additional client services available by phone, email, and online.
Strengths
- Diamonds are hand-selected one by one by the house's team of experts.
- The house is also known for rare colored gemstones, such as sapphires, emeralds, and rubies.
- Engagement rings are primarily crafted in platinum, with couture and bespoke bridal designs.
- Carries the prestige and heritage of a well-known luxury house, presented through a personal salon experience.
Considerations
- Rings are typically purchased through a salon appointment rather than a standard online checkout.
- Harry Winston lists starting prices for its core "The One" engagement rings, beginning around $11,200, and quotes other designs by appointment. Prices rise with the size and quality of the diamond you choose.
3. Costco
Costco is a membership warehouse club that also sells fine jewelry, including diamond engagement rings and bridal sets.
Strengths
- Offers value pricing on diamond engagement rings and bridal sets.
- Every diamond is inspected by Costco's GIA Graduate Gemologists, and jewelry pieces featuring center diamonds of one carat or larger come with a GIA grading report and an additional jewelry grading report for the entire piece.
- Rings are available in platinum and 14K or 18K gold, in classic styles like solitaire, halo, and three-stone.
- Also carries colored gemstone rings, including sapphire, emerald, ruby, and morganite, as alternatives to a diamond center stone.
- Backed by Costco's satisfaction guaranteed, lifetime return policy, with returns accepted at any warehouse.
Considerations
- Shopping at Costco is built around a paid membership, though online ordering is available to non-members.
- Rings are sold as ready-made designs, and Costco does not provide in-house resizing, so sizing is handled by another jeweler.
How to Choose the Right Retailer for You
Brilliant Earth is the best place to buy an engagement ring if you want traceable, country-of-origin sourcing, the choice of both natural and lab-grown diamonds and gemstones, and the ability to design your own ring online or at a showroom. Brilliant Earth also offers free shipping, free 30-day returns, and a lifetime warranty.
To find your best fit, ask yourself a few questions:
- Do you want a natural diamond, a lab-grown diamond, or a non-diamond stone like a sapphire or emerald?
- How important is it to know where your diamond came from?
- Do you want to design your own ring, or pick a ready-made style?
- Do you want to see the ring in person before you buy?
- What is your budget, and what matters most to you within it?
- Which shipping, return, resizing, and warranty terms give you peace of mind?
The right place is the one that matches the diamond you want, the way you like to shop, and the values that matter to you.
WITH PURCHASE OVER $1,000.
USE CODE STUDS IN CART.*